Breastfeeding Doll: Good or Bad Idea for Girls? (POLL)

[ 0 ] July 20, 2011 |

A doll imported from Europe that mimics the act of breastfeeding is causing a stir here in the United States; “Savvy Auntie” Melanie Notkin weighs in on what her followers are saying.

Would you buy a doll that “breastfeeds” for your daughter or niece?

Such a doll that is imported from Spain has some parents wondering if the toy has simply gone too far. The doll, called  “The Breast Milk Baby” and  manufactured by Berjuan Toys, makes motions and sucking noises consistent with breastfeeding, and includes a special top that girls can wear while “breastfeeding” their baby. Berjuan Toys and its supporters say the goal is to encourage nurturing qualities in girls and to bring them up thinking breastfeeding is a healthy, natural way to feed one’s baby.

“The truth is that we’ve received overwhelming support online from all over the country. However, about 20 percent of the messages have been hateful and mean,” said Berjuan Toys U.S. spokesman Dennis Lewis. “Churches all over the world are filled with images of Mary nursing baby Jesus, and yet we can’t imagine letting our daughters learn how important breastfeeding is for our society?”

Lewis noted that even the World Health Organization recommends exclusive breastfeeding for the first six months of life for all babies.

Melanie Notkin, founder of SavvyAuntie.com and author of Savvy Auntie: The Ultimate Guide for Cool Aunts, Great-Aunts, Godmothers, and All Women Who Love Kids(Morrow/HarperCollins), informally polled her Savvy Auntie Facebook Fans about the breastfeeding doll last week, and the majority of Savvy Aunties said they would not buy it for their nieces.

“Many responses included ‘Hell to the no’ and ‘not in a million years.’” Notkin said. “Most aunts felt it was making little girls grow up too fast. Chloe H wondered what happened to kids using their imagination and AnneMarie G questions if it really helps with ‘breastfeeding awareness,’ pointing out that we played with candy cigarettes as kids but that didn’t make us all smokers. Some wondered if little girls would try to breastfeed their neighbor’s real baby since they ‘knew what to do.’”

Notkin added: “Personally, I’d have to agree with the Auntourage on this one. If a little niece wants to mimic her mommy, aunts can buy her a more economical, less technical doll and let her role-play. She’ll find her way if that’s where she wants to go.”

Tell us: Would you buy this doll for your daughter or niece? Please take our poll below and let us know what you think.

Do you think this breastfeeding doll is appropriate for young girls?


View Results

Loading ... Loading ...


For more from Melanie Notkin and parenting experts on genConnect:

Want more genConnect?

  • For more daily expert updates, follow genConnect on Twitter and Facebook.
  • To stay on top of Melanie Notkin’s latest posts, as well as the latest contributions from other experts on the site: Sign Up for genConnect.

These are one expert’s views on the news. Share with us your thoughts in the comments box below.



Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Category: Film, Music and Entertainment, Lifestyle, Views on the News

genConnect Staff

About genConnect Staff:
View author profile.

Comments are closed.